Friday, October 17, 2014

My Kind of Heroine: Does Your Heroine Pass the Bechdel Test? @MelissaSnark #amwriting #Giveaway

  Comment below for a chance to win an ebook copy of A Cat's Tale!

Last month at Convolution 2014 I attended an interesting panel on The Bechdel Test. The discussion covered the roles and perceptions of women in movies, TV, and books. It wasn't the first time I've heard of Bechdel, but it was the first really good debate I've attended on the subject. It struck me as a great fit for the My Kind of Heroine blog series.

TV Tropes defines The Bechdel Test as:

The Bechdel Test, Bechdel-Wallace Test, or the Mo Movie Measure, is a litmus test for female presence in fictional media. The test is named for Alison Bechdel, creator of the comic strip Dykes To Watch Out For,...

To summarize, your story must meet the following criteria in order to pass Bechdel:
  1. Include two named women
  2. who have a minimum of one conversation
  3. about something other than a man or men
Seems simple enough, right? The conditions are easy to understand and apply to any story. What's really interesting though is how easily the results of the Bechdel Test can become distorted. The three criteria don't take context into consideration. Movies that pass may be misogynist at their core, and movies that fail may embody the essence of female empowerment.

Let's look at a few examples from popular culture.

Kill Bill. At a glance, Kill Bill passes Bechdel with flying colors. There are multiple powerful named female characters, and numerous scenes involving women interacting with other women. With a team of highly trained woman assassins, female empowerment appears to be front and center. Yet, at it's core, each of these women is ultimately under the thumb of the manipulative and unscrupulous Bill.(For the record, I enjoyed Kill Bill.)

Hosted on

The Smurfs TV series.  I haven't seen the movie, so I'm going entirely based on childhood memories of the TV series. Smurfette is the only girl in a world of boys. She's vain, flirty, and dingy. A blue Barbie doll who never speaks to another woman, because there no other women in the entire world. Fail.

Star Wars Trilogy. Episodes 4-6.  Bet you wouldn't have guessed Star Wars would fail, would you? In an entire Lucas universe, there are only three named female characters with speaking roles: Princess Leia, Aunt Beru, and Mon Mothma. Yet, none of them ever have share a conversation with each other.*

Naturally, I couldn't write about Bechdel and fail to apply the test to my own books. I'd love to say that my own books passed with flying colors. Except, one didn't. A Cat's Tale, my first published paranormal romance novels, fails in a big way. I do have scenes where named female characters (my heroine and the vampiress villain) speak to each other, but it is always about a man (the hero).


Thankfully, since then, each of my books contains scenes with women talking to women about things other than men. Bearing in mind that Bechdel has limited utility, I also make a concentrated effort to honor the spirit of female empowerment in my fiction.

How about you? How do your stories measure up under Bechdel?

Leave a comment to be entered into a drawing to win an ebook copy of A Cat's Tale. One lucky winner will be selected via

Attribution:  *Film School


  1. It is easy to confuse all kinds of tests that people create so why even bother

  2. Off the top of my head I can't think of any stories that pass the test.

  3. I can`t say 100 percent that anything I have read in the last day or two would pass the test. I do think it is a reasonable standard though. I believe it will be something I recognize going forward.

  4. What always got me was how many movies fail this minimal test. I know one of my three stories pass. One only has one named female character while the rest are men, and I intend to change that. The other is a two character story so it won't pass unless I switch the antagonist's gender.

    It was a good panel. Have you given thought to writing something about the Mako Mori Test they mentioned?

  5. interesting! I think that a lot of the books that I read pass, but not a lot of the movies. Thanks for sharing!

  6. Very interesting, I'll be looking for those in the future.

  7. Jana B,
    Congratulations, you're the winner of an ebook copy of A Cat's Tale! Happy reading! :-)